In the collection How we know

How did Eratosthenes measure the size of the Earth?

Around 240 BC, Eratosthenes compared the Sun's shadow angle at Alexandria with the overhead Sun at Syene, then scaled up the distance between them to get Earth's circumference.

AI-drafted from web search results, then checked by a second, independent AI that read 3 of its 5 cited pages in full and found the thread supported. No person has reviewed it.

0 views
Line diagram of Earth's curved surface with Alexandria and Syene marked, sun rays drawn parallel, vertical lines at each city, a 7 degrees 12 minute angle at the Earth's center, and labels giving 50 times 5000 stadia equals 250,000 stadia.
A diagram of Eratosthenes' method showing the vertical at Alexandria, parallel sun rays, the vertical at Syene (Aswan) well, and the 5000-stadia distance with the 1/50 circle angle. Image: Eratosthenes'_method_for_determining_the_size_of_the_Earth.png : * Eratosthenes', Public domain, via Wikimedia Commons. Chosen automatically; not checked by a person.
Sourced

The short answer

Eratosthenes, a Greek geographer who lived from about 276 to 194 B.C., used shadows and geometry. On one day a year the Sun shone straight down a well at Syene, so it was directly overhead. At the same moment in Alexandria, a vertical post still cast a shadow. The angle of that shadow showed what fraction of a full circle separated the two cities, and the distance between them could then be multiplied up to the whole Earth. [1] [2]

Or ask in your own AI
Sourced

The observations

Eratosthenes heard that at noon on the summer solstice, around June 21, sunlight lit the entire bottom of a well in Syene, now Aswan, and cast no shadow. He took this to mean the Sun was directly overhead. In Alexandria, almost due north, he measured the shadow of a vertical stick or post at noon on the same day and found an angle of about 7.2 degrees, roughly one fiftieth of a circle. Some classroom sources round this to 7 degrees or 7.5 degrees. [2] [1] [3]

Or ask in your own AI
Sourced

The calculation

Because the Sun is so far away, its rays reach Earth almost parallel. The shadow angle in Alexandria therefore equals the angle between the two cities as seen from Earth's center. Since 7.2 degrees is one fiftieth of 360 degrees, the distance between the cities is one fiftieth of the circumference. Eratosthenes put that distance at 5000 stadia, so he multiplied by 50 to reach about 250,000 stadia. The method works for any great circle, not only along a line of longitude. [1] [4]

The distance was reportedly found by hired surveyors called bematists, who were trained to walk with equal steps. This was seen as more reliable than timing camel caravans. One Berkeley astronomy page instead says he estimated the distance from a camel's average speed, so accounts differ on exactly how the figure was obtained. [2] [5]

Or ask in your own AI
Scholars disagree

How accurate was it?

The result depends on the length of the stadium, which scholars do not agree on. Values between about 500 and 600 feet have been suggested, giving a circumference between roughly 24,000 and 29,000 miles. The Berkeley page gives a range of 39,690 to 46,620 km and says the result was within 16 percent of the true polar value of 40,008 km. NOAA gives 28,740 miles, or 45,984 km. NSTA uses a distance of 800 km, which gives about 40,000 km, very close to the modern figure. The modern value is about 24,900 miles around the equator, slightly less around the poles. [2] [5] [1] [4]

His assumptions were not exactly right. He took Alexandria to be due north of Syene and Syene to lie exactly on the Tropic of Cancer. These were close enough for a good measurement. His original manuscript is lost, and his method is known through later Greek writers. [2]

Or ask in your own AI

Where this is

Aswan (Syene), Egypt. Syene, where a well lit fully at noon on the solstice, showing the Sun was directly overhead. Open in Google Maps. Map tiles © Esri and its data providers. Location chosen automatically; not checked by a person.

Sources

  1. Learning Lesson: The Shadow Knows I | National Oceanic and Atmospheric Administration (noaa.gov) Found by source search. Not checked by a person.
  2. Eratosthenes Measures Earth (aps.org) Found by source search. Not checked by a person.
  3. Estimating the size of the Earth | IOPSpark (spark.iop.org) Found by source search. Not checked by a person.
  4. Measuring Shadows to Calculate the Size of Earth | NSTA (nsta.org) Found by source search. Not checked by a person.
  5. Earth Axis | Astronomy (astro.berkeley.edu) Found by source search. Not checked by a person.

Questions to follow next

  • How long was an ancient Greek stadion?
    Or ask in your own AI
  • How can students repeat Eratosthenes' experiment today?
    Or ask in your own AI
  • Did ancient Greeks know the Earth was a sphere?
    Or ask in your own AI

More from How we know

See the collection

Keep going